Stroke units in Nigeria: a report from a Nationwide organizational cross-sectional survey
Babawale Arabambi, Olajumoke Oshinaike, Shamsideen Abayomi Ogun, Chukwuemeka Eze, Abiodun Hamzat Bello, Steven Igetei, Yakub Yusuf, Rashidat Amoke Olanigan, Sikirat Yetunde Ashiru
Received: 25 Apr 2022 - Accepted: 06 Jun 2022 - Published: 22 Jun 2022
Domain: Vascular Neurology
Keywords: Stroke, hospital units, tertiary prevention, Nigeria, acute stroke care
©Babawale Arabambi et al. Pan African Medical Journal (ISSN: 1937-8688). This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Cite this article: Babawale Arabambi et al. Stroke units in Nigeria: a report from a Nationwide organizational cross-sectional survey. Pan African Medical Journal. 2022;42:140. [doi: 10.11604/pamj.2022.42.140.35086]
Available online at: https://www.panafrican-med-journal.com/content/article/42/140/full
Stroke units in Nigeria: a report from a Nationwide organizational cross-sectional survey
Introduction: stroke is one of the leading causes of death and disability in Nigeria. Stroke unit care is crucial for reducing mortality and morbidity in stroke. This study describes the stroke units' structure, organization, and care process in Nigerian tertiary hospitals.
Methods: this study is a cross-sectional descriptive organizational survey-based study using an online structured questionnaire to collect information on the stroke units.
Results: five (8.6%) out of 58 hospitals had a stroke unit. The number of beds ranged between 10 and 27 with the coverage of hospital stroke patients ranging from 24% to 100%. All the centers had a multidisciplinary team for their unit. The basic required investigations like computerized tomography and electrocardiography were available in the centers. Thrombolytic therapy coverage was suboptimal in all the centers due to prolonged onset-to-arrival times and inaccessibility of thrombolytic medications.
Conclusion: there has been some progress in stroke unit availability since the country´s first stroke unit was established over a decade ago. However, there is still the need to create more stroke units in Nigeria and improve reperfusion therapy coverage.
Globally, stroke remains a leading cause of death and disability, with more than 10 million new stroke cases reported in 2019 alone, adding up to over 100 million people living with stroke by the end of that year . In Nigeria, a country with over 200 million people , stroke was second to ischemic heart diseases as a cause of death and disability from a non-communicable disease according to the 2019 data [3,4]. Hospital-based studies in Nigeria between 2004 and 2021 reported 30-day case fatality rates ranging from 21.2% to 40% [5-9]. Proper acute stroke care is critical to survival and achieving favorable functional outcomes in stroke patients. In fact, the care of stroke patients in a stroke unit is a cornerstone of tertiary prevention. Management of stroke patients in a dedicated stroke unit has been shown to improve the chances of being less dependent in the long term and reduce the risk of death and institutionalization . Indeed, stroke care guidelines recommend that stroke patients be treated acutely in an organized setting provided by a dedicated stroke unit .
A stroke unit is a special setting for managing stroke patients, with crucial components including a dedicated ward, a stroke care team that spans various disciplines, and a standard stroke care guideline. Members of the stroke team include neurologists, neurosurgeons, stroke nurses, physical and occupational therapists, speech therapists, dieticians, medical social workers, and other affiliated health professionals. The team works together harmoniously to deliver acute stroke care to the patients [10,12]. The World Stroke Organization (WSO) global stroke guidelines and quality action plan recommend that patients with acute stroke or transient ischemic attack be managed in a stroke unit with at least a stroke care physician, a nurse, and a rehabilitation specialist . Essential services provided by an acute stroke unit should include neurological evaluation and diagnosis of stroke, including neuroimaging (CT scan), electrocardiography (ECG), reperfusion therapy (thrombosis), supportive treatment, monitoring, secondary prevention, and early intensive rehabilitation [13,14]. The Nigerian Stroke Organization (NSO) also recommended that “all stroke patients should be managed in a stroke unit” (Class I recommendation, Level A Evidence) . A global survey reported that only 18% of low-income countries had stroke units, compared to 91% of high-income countries . The first stroke unit in Nigeria was established in 2010 at the University of Benin Teaching Hospital . In 2012, a literature review found that most stroke patients in Nigeria who presented at the hospital were treated in the general medical wards . Given the importance of stroke unit care to the prognosis of the disease in stroke patients, it is necessary to describe the current state of stroke units in the country, focusing on availability, capacity, and capability. This could help support the push for advocacy to establish more stroke units, multi center stroke research collaborations, and standardize stroke care across the centers. This study aimed to describe the available stroke units in Nigerian tertiary hospitals, examining their structure, organization, and care process.
Study design: this cross-sectional descriptive organizational survey-based study was reported using the “Consensus-based checklist for reporting of survey studies (CROSS)” guidelines .
Setting: this study was conducted in Nigeria, one of the most densely populated countries in sub-Saharan Africa . The country is divided into six geopolitical zones - North-East (NE), North-Central (NC), North-West (NW), South-East (SE), South-South (SS), and South-West (SW). Nigeria has 36 states in addition to the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Abuja . Each Nigerian state has at least one tertiary hospital that provides care to patients with neurological disorders, including stroke.
Participants: the study population consisted of teaching hospitals (TH) and federal medical centers (FMC) in Nigeria. These hospitals are classified as tertiary centers because of their patient load and availability of specialist care. The THs are affiliated with different universities and provide medical students and residents training. Ownership and management of the centers were either by the federal government, state governments, or private institutions. The federal government manages the FMCs, typically situated in states without a TH. A total of 58 centers, including 38 THs and 20 FMCs, were identified as potentially eligible for the survey [21,22]. The inclusion of a center was based on the availability of a dedicated stroke unit.
Variables: the main outcomes were latent variables that described stroke unit structure and organization, stroke unit care process, discharge and follow-up, and data management in a stroke registry. Since this study was a descriptive rather than analytical study, predictors or confounders were not relevant to the context.
Data sources and measurement: the data collection instrument was a structured questionnaire with five sections. The first and second sections collected information on center classification and availability of a neurology unit and a stroke unit. The third section examined the stroke unit structure and organization with questions on capacity, staffing, patient load, criteria for admission, multidisciplinary meetings, and training programs. The fourth section focused on the unit's care process, including treatment guidelines, pre-admission procedures, available investigations, assessment scales, nursing and physiotherapy assessment, supportive care equipment, thrombolytic therapy, and mechanical thrombectomy. The final section elicited the discharge and follow-up plans and data management in a stroke registry. The questionnaire was formulated via consensus after discussion between the authors BA, SAO, and OO. Validation rules were attached to all the questions, and the authors pretested the instrument before deployment. The questionnaire (“A snapshot of stroke units in Nigeria”) was shared as a Google forms survey and administered between March 3rd and 16th, 2022. The forms were shared with neurologists or neurology residents in centers with stroke units, who were actively involved in providing care to admitted stroke patients.
Statistical methods: data were qualitatively described and presented in tables. Selection of participating hospitals was summarized using a flowchart. Data cleaning, conversion, and summaries of frequencies and range were done using R studio .
Out of 58 hospitals, only five centers (8.8%) had a dedicated stroke unit (Figure 1). Of the five centers included in the study, two were in South-West Nigeria, one each in the country's south-south, south-east, and north-central regions. Four of them were federal THs, while the last one was a state TH.
Stroke unit structure and organization: the first center was established in 2010, while the most recent unit started in 2021. Most centers had ten beds in the stroke ward, with the biggest center operating with 27 beds. In each shift, the nurses per bed ranged from one nurse per seven beds to one nurse per two beds. The stroke units admitted 24% to 100% of all stroke patients in these centers six months before the survey. All the centers had neurosurgeons (NS), physiotherapists (PTs), radiologists, and medical social workers (MSWs), while most of the centers had speech and language therapists (SLTs), psychiatrists, and nutritionists. However, only two centers had occupational therapists (OTs). Typical exclusion criteria for admission into the stroke wards included stroke duration greater than seven days and severe strokes requiring intensive care. Most centers had multidisciplinary team meetings and educational programs for their staff. Other details are shown in Table 1.
Stroke unit care process: all the centers had definite, accessible guidelines for managing patients admitted into the stroke unit. Patients admitted to the units had detailed neurological history and examination taken, were assessed early by PT/OT, had swallow tests, strict input-output charting, and closely monitored vital signs. All the centers had at least a brain computerized tomography (CT) available for their stroke patients, though the CT suites were not domiciled in the stroke unit. Further details of the care processes are shown in Table 2. Centers also had facilities for viral studies like SARS-CoV-2 and HIV and had access to typical investigations for evaluation of stroke in young people. Only two centers had given thrombolytic therapy to their stroke patients. The lack of thrombosis was due to affordability, unavailability of medications, delayed onset-to-arrival time and delayed door-to-needle time. None of the centers were capable of a mechanical thrombectomy procedure.
Stroke unit discharge/follow-up and data management: the average length of stay in the stroke units ranged from 7 to 20 days, with the usual discharge destination being the neurology clinic. Three centers had their local stroke registry where they input the data for admitted patients. Two of the centers (LASUTH and LUTH) participated in an international stroke registry.
This study provides a snapshot of stroke units in Nigeria. The mode of collection of information may be associated with some accuracy issues. Still, the breadth of information given is a good starting point for describing what is available for this vital aspect of stroke care. Stroke unit coverage in Nigeria is still suboptimal, with only a few centers having stroke units. The units in most of these centers are not large enough to provide care for all admitted acute stroke patients. Besides guidelines that recommend stroke unit care for better patient outcomes [10,11], several other studies have supported this recommendation in real-life settings across different geographical contexts [24-30]. A previous study in Australia concluded that any hospital that admits more than 100 stroke patients in a year should have a stroke unit . Although we do not have the data on annual stroke admissions in Nigerian tertiary hospitals from our study, we can extrapolate from the five included centers that most of the other centers would cross the threshold for the need for a stroke center. None of the FMCs or private THs had a stroke unit. While the reason for this skewness is unclear, funding and staffing deficiencies may have a role to play. The hindrances to establishing stroke units in Nigerian tertiary hospitals are multifaceted. Implementation and maintenance of the unit are capital-intensive. Indeed, neuroimaging equipment, continuous cardiac monitoring devices, and well-trained staff are essential for the seamless operation of a stroke ward . Resolving these challenges requires advocacy at the government level for the establishment of more stroke units . Furthermore, collaboration with centers already providing standard stroke care for training, telemedicine, and research purposes is beneficial .
The availability of nurses in the stroke ward is directly associated with early stroke outcomes, with centers with a higher nurse-to-bed ratio performing better than those with a lower ratio [34,35]. Payley et al. suggested three trained nurses per 10 beds  for optimal outcomes. Some of the centers in these studies would benefit from increasing the number of nurses in their units. Multidisciplinary coverage was adequate in the centers; however, some centers did not have interdisciplinary team meetings with their patients and relatives. These meetings are essential because they provide an opportunity to harmonize management decisions, respond to patient concerns, allay their fears, and plan long-term rehabilitation and follow-up. The hospital length of stay of 7 to 20 days reported in this survey is comparable to reports of 10 days on average from previous studies in sub-Saharan African countries [36,37].
According to a survey of stroke experts, the minimum investigations required for stroke unit care were brain CT (prioritized for stroke patients), carotid Doppler, and ECG . A previous study of stroke patients in a Cameroonian medical unit confirmed the importance of brain CT in mortality reduction in a resource-constrained setting . Recent studies have suggested an increase in the prevalence of extracranial carotid atherosclerosis in Africans [40,41]. Additionally, carotid artery disease has been shown to increase the risk of stroke independently in Nigeria . This trend suggests that a carotid Doppler may be necessary for all admitted stroke patients in Nigeria. The use of thrombolytic therapy remains a significant challenge. Inaccessibility of thrombolytic treatment has also been reported in other developing countries [33,36]. Known reasons for lack of thrombosis include cost  and delayed presentations, with prolonged onset-to-arrival and door-to-needle time . For context, most health services in Nigeria are paid for out-of-pocket, with close to 97% of the population without any health insurance coverage . While the minimum wage in Nigeria is 30,000 Naira (equivalent to 70 US dollars), the cost for a complete infusion of intravenous Alteplase, according to “drugstore.ng,” is over a million Naira (more than 2,500 US dollars). Therefore, thrombolytic therapy is prohibitively expensive and is not routinely stocked by pharmaceutical outlets. Furthermore, previous studies in Nigeria have identified significant delays in presenting to the hospital, with less than 10% of patients with ischemic stroke getting admitted within the thrombolytic window [6,45]. Reasons for delayed onset-to-arrival time, as identified from previous studies, include a lack of awareness of symptoms and the belief that stroke is a “spiritual attack” that is better treated using spiritual and herbal remedies [46,47]. Overall, while there have been more stroke units established since the first one in 2010, Nigeria still needs to improve tertiary stroke prevention by adding more stroke units to reduce the impact of stroke on mortality and disability. The loss of life years would affect not only the patient but also their caregivers and dependents. Additionally, existing units should be improved in terms of the number of nurses and the provision of thrombolytic therapy, with a plan to start mechanical thrombectomy. At the level of the government, advocacy for the establishment of more stroke units and subsidization of thrombolytic treatment will be beneficial in the long term. Potential challenges to establishing more stroke units and improving existing ones include cost, human resources, and incompatibility with existing systems. However, the evidence is unequivocal regarding the benefits of these units outweighing the costs.
Setting up more and improving existing stroke units in the various centers in Nigeria should be advocated and encouraged to enhance tertiary prevention, thus reducing disability and mortality, and improving stroke outcomes.
What is known about this topic
- Stroke unit treatment are critical to improving stroke outcome;
- Stroke is one of the leading causes of mortality and morbidity in Nigeria.
What this study adds
- Documents the status of stroke units in Nigeria regarding availability and capacity;
- Emphasizes the need to improve on the existing stroke units in addition to establishing more units.
The authors declare no competing interests.
BA conceived the study; BA, OO, and SAO were involved in study design and creation of survey instrument; BA, CE, AHB, SI, YY, RAO, and SA Oimplemented the study; BA did the data analysis; BA and SAO wrote the first draft of the paper. All the authors have read and agreed to the final manuscript.
- Feigin VL, Stark BA, Johnson CO, Roth GA, Bisignano C, Abady GG et al. Global, regional, and national burden of stroke and its risk factors, 1990-2019: a systematic analysis for the Global burden of disease study 2019. Lancet Neurol. 2021 Oct;20(10):795-820. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Worldometer. African countries by population (2022). Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Statista. Nigeria: main causes of death 2019. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation. Nigeria. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Njoku CH, Aduloju AB. Stroke in Sokoto, Nigeria: a five year retrospective study. Annals of African Medicine. 2004 Nov 16;3(2):73-6. Google Scholar
- Arabambi B, Oshinaike O, Akilo O, Yusuf Y, Ogun S. Pattern, risk factors, and outcome of acute stroke in a Nigerian university teaching hospital: a 1-year review. Nigerian Journal of Medicine. 2021 Jun 30;30(3):252-6. Google Scholar
- Ekeh B, Ogunniyi A, Isamade E, Ekrikpo U. Stroke mortality and its predictors in a Nigerian teaching hospital. Afr Health Sci. 2015 Mar;15(1):74-81. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Ogun SA, Ojini FI, Ogungbo B, Kolapo KO, Danesi MA. Stroke in south west Nigeria: a 10-year review. Stroke. 2005 Jun;36(6):1120-2. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Sanya E, Wahab K, Bello A, Alaofin W, Ademiluyi B. In-hospital stroke mortality and its predictors within one month of ictus: result from a tertiary hospital in Ilorin, middle belt Nigeria. Sub-Saharan African Journal of Medicine. 2015 Oct 1;2(4):165. Google Scholar
- Langhorne P, Ramachandra S, Stroke Unit Trialists C. Organised inpatient (stroke unit) care for stroke: network meta-analysis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020 Apr 23;4(4):CD000197. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Adeoye O, Nyström KV, Yavagal DR, Luciano J, Nogueira RG, Zorowitz RD et al . Recommendations for the establishment of stroke systems of care: a 2019 update. Stroke. 2019 Jul;50(7):e187-e210. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Riks-Stroke Collaboration. Definition of a stroke unit. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Lindsay P, Furie KL, Davis SM, Donnan GA, Norrving B. World Stroke Organization global stroke services guidelines and action plan. Int J Stroke. 2014 Oct;9 Suppl A100:4-13. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Rodgers H, Price C. Stroke unit care, inpatient rehabilitation and early supported discharge. Clin Med (Lond). 2017 Apr;17(2):173-177 PubMed | Google Scholar
- Nigerian Stroke Society. Guidelines for prevention and management of patient with ischemic stroke or transient ischemic attack. Unpublished. 2009.
- Owolabi MO, Thrift AG, Martins S, Johnson W, Pandian J, Abd-Allah F et al. The state of stroke services across the globe: report of World Stroke Organization-World Health Organization surveys. Int J Stroke. 2021 Oct;16(8):889-901. PubMed | Google Scholar
- University of Benin Teaching Hospital (UBTH). The first stroke ward in nigeria @ 10. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Bell-Gam HI, Onwuchekwa A, Iyagba AM. Improving stroke management through specialized stroke units in nigeria: a situational review. The Nigerian Health Journal. 2012;12(2):31-4. Google Scholar
- Sharma A, Minh Duc NT, Luu Lam Thang T, Nam NH, Ng SJ, Abbas KS et al. A consensus-based checklist for reporting of survey studies (CROSS). J Gen Intern Med. 2021 Oct;36(10):3179-3187. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Eze TC, Okpala CS, Ogbodo JC. Patterns of inequality in human development Across Nigeria's six geopolitical zones. Dev Country Stud.2014;4(8):97-101. Google Scholar
- Federal Ministry of Health. Federal Medical Centres. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Public Health Nigeria. List of federal, state and private teaching hospitals in Nigeria. 2020. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- R Core Team. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. 2013. Google Scholar
- Burgess NG, Vyas R, Hudson J, Browne O, Lee YC, Jayathissa S et al. Improved stroke care processes and outcomes following the institution of an acute stroke unit at a New Zealand district general hospital. N Z Med J. 2012 Oct 26;125(1364):37-46. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Candelise L, Gattinoni M, Bersano A, Micieli G, Sterzi R, Morabito A et al. Stroke-unit care for acute stroke patients: an observational follow-up study. Lancet. 2007 Jan 27;369(9558):299-305. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Cisse FA, Damien C, Bah AK, Toure ML, Barry M, Djibo Hamani AB et al. Minimal setting stroke unit in a sub-Saharan African public hospital. Front Neurol. 2019 Aug 7;10:856. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Di Carlo A, Lamassa M, Wellwood I, Bovis F, Baldereschi M, Nencini P et al. Stroke unit care in clinical practice: an observational study in the Florence center of the European Registers of Stroke (EROS) project. Eur J Neurol. 2011 May;18(5):686-94. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Gattellari M, Worthington J, Jalaludin B, Mohsin M. Stroke unit care in a real-life setting: can results from randomized controlled trials be translated into every-day clinical practice? An observational study of hospital data in a large Australian population. Stroke. 2009 Jan;40(1):10-7. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Tu WJ, Yan F, Chao BH, Ji XM, Wang L. Stroke-unit care for stroke patients in China: the results from bigdata observatory platform for Stroke of China. J Neurol. 2021 Nov;268(11):4213-4220. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Turner M, Barber M, Dodds H, Dennis M, Langhorne P, Macleod MJ et al. The impact of stroke unit care on outcome in a Scottish stroke population, taking into account case mix and selection bias. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2015 Mar;86(3):314-8. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Cadilhac DA, Kilkenny MF, Andrew NE, Ritchie E, Hill K, Lalor E et al. Hospitals admitting at least 100 patients with stroke a year should have a stroke unit: a case study from Australia. BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Mar 16;17(1):212 PubMed | Google Scholar
- Gadama YG, Mwangalika G, Kinley LB, Jackson B, Mwandumba HC, Mallewa J et al. Challenges of stroke management in resource-limited settings: a case-based reflection. Malawi Med J. 2017 Jun;29(2):189-193. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Durai Pandian J, Padma V, Vijaya P, Sylaja PN, Murthy JM. Stroke and thrombolysis in developing countries. Int J Stroke. 2007 Feb;2(1):17-26. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Paley L, Williamson E, Bray BD, Hoffman A, James MA, Rudd AG. Associations between 30-day mortality, specialist nursing, and daily physician ward rounds in a national stroke registry. Stroke. 2018 Sep;49(9):2155-2162. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Bray BD, Ayis S, Campbell J, Cloud GC, James M, Hoffman A et al. Associations between stroke mortality and weekend working by stroke specialist physicians and registered nurses: prospective multicentre cohort study. PLoS Medicine. 2014;11(8):e1001705. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Gadama Y, Kamtchum-Tatuene J, Benjamin L, Phiri T, Mwandumba HC. The significant gap between international standards and stroke management practices at Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital (Malawi): an audit report. Malawi Med J. 2019 Dec;31(4):249-255. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Lekoubou A, Nkoke C, Dzudie A, Kengne AP. Stroke admission and case-fatality in an urban medical unit in sub-Saharan Africa: a fourteen year trend study from 1999 to 2012. J Neurol Sci. 2015 Mar 15;350(1-2):24-32. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Leys D, Ringelstein EB, Kaste M, Hacke W. The main components of stroke unit care: results of a European expert survey. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2007;23(5-6):344-52. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Lekoubou A, Nkoke C, Dudzie A, Kengne AP. Computed tomography scanning and stroke mortality in an urban medical unit in Cameroon. eNeurologicalSci. 2016 Mar;2:3-7. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Khedr E, Tony AA, Habeel M, Nasreldein A. Frequency and risk factors of carotid artery disease among ischemic stroke patients in the south Egypt: hospital-based study. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery. 2021 Dec;57(1):1-6. Google Scholar
- Omisore AD, Famurewa OC, Komolafe MA, Asaleye CM, Fawale MB, Afolabi BI. Association of traditional cardiovascular risk factors with carotid atherosclerosis among adults at a teaching hospital in south-western Nigeria. Cardiovasc J Afr. 2018 May/Jun 23;29(3):183-188. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Owolabi MO, Akpa OM, Agunloye AM. Carotid IMT is more associated with stroke than risk calculators. Acta Neurol Scand. 2016 Jun;133(6):442-50. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Akinyemi RO, Ovbiagele B, Adeniji OA, Sarfo FS, Abd-Allah F, Adoukonou T et al. Stroke in Africa: profile, progress, prospects and priorities. Nat Rev Neurol. 2021 Oct;17(10):634-656. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Sasu DD. Nigeria: health insurance coverage, by type and gender. Accessed on Apr 25, 2022.
- Ogbole GI, Owolabi MO, Ogun O, Ogunseyinde OA, Ogunniyi A. Time of presentation of stroke patients for CT imaging in a Nigerian Tertiary Hospital. Ann Ib Postgrad Med. 2015 Jun;13(1):23-8. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Philip-Ephraim EE, Charidimou A, Otu AA, Eyong EK, Williams UE, Ephraim RP. Factors associated with prehospital delay among stroke patients in a developing African Country. Int J Stroke. 2015 Jun;10(4):E39. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Nweke MC, Eze CK. The place of spiritual and traditional beliefs in stroke rehabilitation in sub-saharan africa: a scoping review. J Complement Altern Med Res. 2019;8:1-6. Google Scholar