Correlation of HIV-1 drug resistant mutations and virologic failure
Olipher Makwaga1,&, David Hughes Mulama2, John Muoma2, Matilu Mwau1
1Kenya Medical Research Institute, Busia, Kenya, 2Masinde Muliro University of Science and Technology, Kakamega, Kenya
Olipher Makwaga, Kenya Medical Research Institute, Busia, Kenya
mutations are important by ensuring that the HIV-1 agent remains fit in the environment and evades drugs that are developed purposely to kill them. In Kenya, mutations conferring resistance to available ARVs have been reported in previous studies. However, there is a paucity of information on whether these previous studies have reported all mutations conclusively that confer resistance to available drugs leading to virologic failure. Therefore, this study was sought to identify the current HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations attributable to virologic failure among adults on various ARV regimens.
the samples were collected in March to June 2020. Analysis of viral loads and HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations through sequencing of the pol region of HIV-1 were done. Alignment of the cDNA sequences was done by Recall (beta version 3.05) software. HIV-1 resistant mutations were identified by Stanford University HIV drug resistance database.
most of the participants had viral loads of more than 1000 copies/ml during all the three visits. Out of 125 mutations identified, 83 mutations resulted in virologic failure. Out of 17 new mutations, 14 resulted in virologic failure and included NRTIs (L74I, L74V, T69D, V65R); NNRTIs (A98G, V179E, V179F, V179D, 179F); PIs (I54V3, F53L2, L89T, G48A).
the study reveals new HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations which have never been reported in Kenya as well as old and both resulted in virologic failure. This calls for frequent monitoring and profiling of mutations that will enable decision-making in the drugs and vaccine design and development.
In Kenya, approximately 1.5m persons are living with HIV with annual new cases of 35000 and 6800 and deaths of 17000 and 4300 among adults and children respectively. Out of a total of 47 counties in Kenya, Busia is 5th with an HIV-1 prevalence of 7.7%. ART uptake is the only option for all infected persons due to its ability to decrease HIV-1 viral tally while boosting the immune system against opportunistic infections. Nationally, about 75% and 84% of the HIV-infected adults and children are receiving ART. Consequently, a coverage uptake of ARVs in Busia is 95% and 78% among adults and children respectively . Irrespective of these mileposts in the management of HIV, HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations have become a life-threatening issue because they aid the virus to evade and proliferate in the presence of drugs thus intimidating the success of management of the HIV infection.
Currently, four sets of ARVs are used to manage HIV infection in Kenya. These include NNRTIs (Nevirapine (NVP), Efavirenz (EFV)); NRTIs (Lamivudine (3TC), Abacavir (ABC), Azidovodine (AZT)), Tenofovir-disoproxil-fumarate (TDF); PIs (Lopinavir plus ritonavir (LPV/r), Atazanavir plus ritonavir (ATV/r)) and Intergrase (Dolutegravir (DTG)) .The development of mutations by the HIV against these single-dose treatments initially frustrated the success of management of the infection. Consequently, further development of mutations against the above drug combination regimen therapy has also become a threat to the entire management of HIV infections.
In Kenya, mutations conferring resistance to available ARVs has been reported in past studies. These mutations included M184V, K65R,D67N,K70R,K219Q,Q151M, T215F, M41L, T69N, V75M, M41L, T69N, V75M, D67G, V75M, M184I, T215N, M41LM, T215N, K219N,210W, T215Y as NRTIs; K103N/S, Y181C/Y/I/V, G190A/S, L100I,V179T, V106I/A, V108I, P225H, M230L, K238T, P225H, F227L as NNRTIs; M46I/L, D30N,M46I,V82F,L90M as PIs [3-15]. However, these studies did not link the mutations with the viral tallies and ARVs the participants were taking. Therefore, this study aimed to link the mutations with the viral tallies and ARVs the participants were taking as well as identify other new mutations encoding resistance to available classes of ARVs. This information will advance the knowledge on the evolutionary pattern of HIV-1virus in Kenya and attract a change of treatment options.
Study design, study site and population
The study design was cross sectional including adults of Busia attending a Comprehensive Care Clinic of Busia county referral hospital. Busia is among the 47 counties of Kenya. Busia county is number five in the country with the highest prevalence of HIV. Moreover, its prevalence is higher than nationwide . It is situated alongside the Kenya-Uganda boundary. Busia county referral hospital where the study was conducted, is a reference level four hospital in the region with a high capacity hospital patient attendance. The hospital is similarly among the health facilities which benefits from the Academic Model Providing Access to Healthcare (AMPATH)Integrating Nutrition Support initiative where recently HIV infected individuals are aggressively registered for ARVs and old ones are reserved on ARVs by providing food to HIV infected persons and their dependents . AMPATH is an academic medical partnership between North American academic health centers led by the Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis, Indiana and the Moi University School of Medicine, centered in Eldoret, Kenya. The participants who were included in the study were HIV-1 infected and taking ARVs treatment, were aged ≥ 18 years and consented to participate.
Sample size determination: a formula by  was used to compute the minimum number of samples:
n = minimum sample size; Zcrit is the standard normal deviation = 1.96 (standard errors from the mean) at D = 0.05% level of significance, p = prevalence of infection. The prevalence of 1.1% of HIV Type 1 drug-resistance among adults in a rural HIV clinic in Kenya  being too low for this study, we averaged these by an overall prevalence of 4.7% of drug-resistant HIV-1 transmission in Africa  to compute our sample size and this was 2.9%. p= 0.029 HIV-1 drug resistance prevalence, therefore, n= 43 blood samples which were rounded to 50.
All adult participants attending a comprehensive HIV care Clinic of Busia county-referral hospital from the months of March to June 2020, already taking ARVs and consented to participate in the study were recruited systematically. Demographics (age and sex) and duration on ARVs were collected through interview using a simple questionnaire by a qualified health officer. The questionnaire was written in both English and Swahili which are both the national languages for Kenya. The clinicians requested the participants to decide on one language they were very much conversant with so that the correct information could be collected. About 5 ml of blood samples were collected using sterile needles and syringes in EDTA tubes by qualified medical laboratory Technologists. Triple packaging of the samples was done and transported to KEMRI laboratory following the national sample consignment program for clinical specimens. Samples were removed from the cold environment and allowed to come to room temperature for at least one hour before processing.
Viral load and HIV-1 drug-resistance testing
Samples for analyzing viral load were collected in plasma preparation tubes (Becton-Dickinson, San-Jose, CA-USA). Plasma were mixed into cryo-tubes. Extraction and quantification of RNA was carried out in Abbott real time machine (Abbott Molecular Inc. USA) and Cobas-Ampliprep/ Cobas-Taqman HIV-1 test v.2.0 (Roche Diagnostic, USA) according to manufacturer´s procedures .
Transcription of RNA into cDNA was carried out using an in-house reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) protocol by Thermo Fisher Scientific´s Genotyping kit. The extracted-RNA was denatured at 65°C for 10 minutes. The RT -PCR was carried out following these cycling environments: 1 cycle of reverse-transcription at 500C for 45 minutes, 1 cycle of enzyme inactivation at 940C for 2 minutes, 40 cycles of denaturation at 940C for 15 seconds, 40 cycles of annealing at 500C for 20 seconds, 40 cycles of extension at 720C for 2 minutes and one cycle of final extension at 720C for 10 minutes. The nested PCR was done under the following cycling conditions: one cycle of initial denaturation at 940C for 4 minutes, 40 cycles of denaturation at 940C for 15 seconds, 40 cycles of annealing at 550C for 20 seconds, 40 cycles of extension at 720C for 2 minutes and one cycle of final extension at 720C for 10 minutes. Agarose gel (1%) was used to confirm the PCR amplified results. Gel electrophoresis was done for confirmation of the amplified DNA by the gel visualization on the imaging system and photographed. Purification of the PCR products was performed using Thermo Fisher Scientific´s Clean Sweep Purification Reagent under the following conditions: Digest at 370C for 15 minutes and heat deactivation at 800C for 15 minutes. Cycle sequencing was done using 6 sequencing mixes (F1, F2, F3, R1, R2, and R3) and PGEM sequencing control. The cycle sequencing conditions was set at 25 cycles of denaturation, annealing and extension at 96°C for 10 seconds, 50°C for 5 seconds, and 60°C for 4 minutes respectively. Purification of cycle sequencing products was done using Thermo Fisher Scientific´s Big Dye X-Terminator Purification Kit.
Direct sequencing of the pol gene encoding protease (codons 6-99) and reverse transcriptase (codons 1-239) was done on the 3730XL DNA Analyzer (Applied Biosytems) using Sanger sequencer. Base calling was facilitated by Seq Scanner v.6 (Applied Bio systems Inc. USA). This was by evaluating the main technical parameters (i.e., raw data, electropherograms and the quality value of sequenced bases). RECall (beta v3.05) software (http://pssm.cfenet.ubc.ca/) was used for aligning and generating the consensus sequences and Drug-resistance was determined using the International Aids Society (IAS) algorithm and the Stanford University HIV database.
Ethical approval and considerations
All ethical processes were considered. Scientific and Ethical clearance for this study was sought from the national ethical review committee at Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI) which issued a study number KEMRI/SERU/CIPDCR/008/3333. This study involved the analysis of clinical specimens. Blood samples were collected and coded without using any participant´s identifier. Other relevant information was collected orally on a simple questionnaire by qualified health officers in Busia referral hospital. These questionnaires were kept under lockable cabinets and accessed only by Investigators. The samples were taken to KEMRI laboratory for PCR and sequencing using the recommended national courier services in the country. The results were interpreted by investigators in a language that the clinicians understood. All the soft data and write ups of this study had password protected so as to be accessed only by Investigators. Thereafter, both original and interpreted results were sent back to the health facility using courier services so that they are released to clinicians and participants. The results of this study enabled the participants to have information whether the drugs they are taking are working well or not and why they may be changed to other ARVs. Clinicians used these results to manage participants appropriately.
Data management and statistical analysis
Collected data was entered, cleaned and stored in excel in columns of variables in a password protected desktop and only accessible to Investigators. Hard disk and external drive was used to back up the data. Analysis of data was conducted by employing SPSS v. 20 (Armonk NY: IBM, Corp). The key variables were HIV-1 drug resistant mutations and viral tallies. Descriptive measurements were carried out to analyze socio demographic characteristics and the frequency of various HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations. Viral tallies generated by the Cobas-Ampliprep/ Cobas-Taqman were converted into log10 using a scientific calculator. Pearson´s correlation was used to link the viral tallies and various mutations, whereby a negative and a positive figure marked the relationship. Paired sample t test was used to establish a p value between mutations and the viral tallies of which a p value of less than 0.05 was termed as significant. Systematic reviews of 200 related papers to this study in Kenya were identified through MEDLINE and EMBASE of which 23 were eligible for inclusion in the review and five from other sources.
About 50 (female, 31 and male, 19) participants were included in
the current study. Their age range was from 18 to 66 years old
(median age 35; interquartile ranges 28 years). Many participants were on
and TDF+3TC+EFV ARVs regimen combination (Table
Table 2 shows
correlations between specific mutations, ARV regimen the participants were taking,
and viral loads of the three consecutive visits of 34 participants whose samples
had mutations. Each specific mutation conferring resistance to a certain drug
of a given participant is highlighted with the same color. Some mutations existed
which did not confer resistance to the drugs the patients were taking. This does
not mean that the mutations are not important; they are because they confer resistance
to other drugs as per the Stanford University HIV drug resistance database. Higher
viral loads in all participants persisted. Most of the old mutations identified
in the previous studies encoded resistance to prescribed drugs causing virologic
failure. Most of the new mutations also encoded for resistance to prescribed
drugs and these included L74I/V, T69D, V65R as NRTIs; A98G, V179E/F/D/F as NNRTs
and I54V, F53L, L89T, G48A, K20T as PIs. Pearson´s correlation; r = 0.311
and a p value of 0.028 between viral tallies and all the mutations showed a strong
positive relationship between these two variables. Thus participants are likely
to have mutations with the increasing viral loads in the presence of ARVs uptakes.
The importance of ARV treatment in HIV infected persons is massive as it prolongs their survival, advances their value of life and minimizes the morbidity and mortality rates . ARV treatment is the standard care for all HIV infected persons in Kenya . However, there is a contest due to HIV drug-resistant mutations which weakens effectiveness of the drug. Subsequently, HIV-1 drug-resistance testing is significant in resolution making concerning the management of HIV infected persons . However, HIV-1 drug-resistance tests are not routinely available in the country and are only carried out in limited research laboratories in Kenya.
The study was planned to identify both old and new mutations that confer resistance to the drugs participants were taking in relation to virologic failure. Additional HIV infection was regularly detected in women more than men, endorsing past studies [10, 13] that the prevalence of HIV among women is more than that of men in the country and that men are poor health pursuers compared to women. Further analyses demonstrated that the proportion of women to men in this study was similar, giving a podium of gender assessment as it is reported with National AIDS and STI Control Program (NASCOP) that fairly more women are infected with HIV than men .
In broad, the study determined the current HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations attributable to virologic failure among adults on various ARV regimens. The study noted the current drug regimen combinations which the participants were taking. Additionally, the viral loads for the three consecutive visits were determined. Further, the specific mutations encoding for resistance to various classes/types of ARVs were analyzed.
In the current study, participants were taking 10 diverse regimens of ARVs that are regularly accessible. Additional analysis showed that many participants were taking TDF+3TC+EFV and AZT+3TC+NVP as first line HIV-1 treatment because the former regimen is standby first line ART regimen and the latter is ideal first line ART regimen in pregnancy. These outcomes concur with the fact that many women were put on these two drugs than other regimens of ARVs. This study did not investigate pregnancy history. AZT+3TC+ATV/r was being taken by many participants compared to other second line drugs, perhaps due to the guidelines that after failure on the above ideal and substitute of first line drugs, the patient be switched to AZT+3TC+ATV/r as a second-line drug , evidenced by our study that more participants were taking the two first line drugs compared to the rest. Most of the participants had persisting higher viral tally during all the visits. This was a sign of virologic failure which was justified by the presence of multiple mutations in the samples of the participants.
Previous related studies [3-15] identified some of the mutations that were identified in this study, however, our study reports other several new mutations of clinical importance which were not reported in the previous studies. The existence of these new mutations that encode resistance to the present drugs the participants are currently undertaking. Furthermore, the strong positive relationship between the viral loads and mutations displayed in this study intimidates the entire management of HIV infection. Therefore, the current data increases evidence to the earlier literature on HIV-1 drug-resistance. It also informs in the verdict making regarding the treatment selections midst diseased persons. Information in this study pleas for strengthening of the health systems in the Country.
Limitation of the study: our study concentrated on the determining of HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations by sequencing the pol gene. This would underrate the general mutations. This is because some drugs mark the gag as well as envelope genes of the HIV. Therefore, we recommend in such situations, all the three genes to be sequenced.
The study reveals new HIV-1 drug-resistant mutations which have never been reported in Kenya as well as old and both result to virologic failure. This calls for frequent monitoring and profiling of mutations that will enable decision-making in the drug design and development.
What is known about this topic
- HIV drug-resistance is a threat to the general population;
- Presently, HIV infected individuals entirely are started on treatment irrespective of their CD4 counts;
- ART uptake is increasing in all the Kenyan counties.
What this study adds
- Data collected in this study increments information to the previously existing literature on HIV-1 drug-resistance;
- Evidence in this study will enlighten in the decision making regarding treatment choices amongst infected individuals;
- Materials in this study calls for health systems strengthening in the county and in the entire Country.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Olipher Makwaga: conceptualization, funding acquisition, data curation, formal analysis, investigation, methodology, validation, writing-original draft, writing-review and editing. David Hughes Mulama: data curation, formal analysis, investigation, methodology, validation, writing - original draft. Matilu Mwau: funding acquisition, project administration, resources, writing original-draft, writing-review & editing. John Muoma: investigation, methodology, validation, visualization, writing - original draft. All authors read and approved to final version of the manuscript.
Our appreciation goes to all participants in this study. This study was supported financially by Government of Kenya, KEMRI Research grant and Research fund of the Kenyan National government.
Table 1: gender and ARVs Regimen combination enrolled participants were taking, n = 50
Table 2: correlation of mutations identified and viral loads of participants on various ARVs, n = 34
- World Health Organization. Everybody´s business: Strengthening health systems to improve health outcomes. WHO´S framework for action. 2020.
- Ministry of Health: Guidelines on the use of antiretroviral drugs for treating and preventing HIV infection in Kenya. Report 2018, Nairobi, Kenya. Google Scholar
- Aghokeng AF, Kouanfack C, Laurent C, Ebong E, Atem-Tambe A, Butel C et al. Scale-up of antiretroviral treatment in sub-Saharan Africa is accompanied by increasing HIV-1 drug resistance mutations in drug-naive patients. AIDS. 2011 Nov 13;25(17):2183-8. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Budambula V, Musumba FO, Webale MK KT, Ongecha-Owuor F, Kiarie JN et al. HIV-1 protease inhibitor drug resistance in Kenyan antiretroviral treatment-naive and -experienced injection drug users and non-drug users. AIDS Research and Therapy. 2015 Aug 15;12:27. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Hassan AS, Mwaringa SM, Obonyo CA, Nabwera HM, Sanders EJ, Rinke de Wit TF et al. Low prevalence of transmitted HIV type 1 drug resistance among antiretroviral-naive adults in a rural HIV clinic in Kenya. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses. 2013 Jan;29(1):129-35. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Kinyua JG, Lihana RW, Kiptoo M, Muasya T, Odera I, Muiruri P et al. Antiretroviral resistance among HIV-1 patients on first-line therapy attending a comprehensive care clinic in Kenyatta National Hospital, Kenya: a retrospective analysis. PanAfrica Medical Journal. 2018 Apr 2;29:186 eCollection 2018. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Kiptoo M, Brooks J, Lihana RW, Sandstrom P, Ng´ang´a Z, Kinyua J et al. HIV-1 drug resistance-associated mutations among HIV-1 infected drug-naïve antenatal clinic attendees in rural Kenya BMC Infect Dis. 2013 Nov 4;13:517. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Koigi P, Ngayo MO, Khamadi S, Ngugi C, Nyamache AK. HIV type 1 drug resistance patterns among patients failing first and second line antiretroviral therapy in Nairobi, Kenya BMC Res Notes. 2014 Dec 9;7:890. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Ochieng W, Kitawi RC, Nzomo TJ, Mwatelah RS, Kimulwo MJ, Ochieng DJ et al. Implementation and Operational Research: Correlates of Adherence and Treatment Failure Among Kenyan Patients on Long-term Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome. 2015 Jun 1;69(2):e49-56. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Onywera H, Maman D, Inzaule S, Auma E, Were K, Fredrick H et al. Surveillance of HIV-1 pol transmitted drug resistance in acutely and recently infected antiretroviral drug-naive persons in rural western Kenya PLoS One. 2017 Feb 8;12(2):e0171124. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Osman S, Lihana RW, Kibaya RM, Ishizaki A, Bi X, Okoth FA et al. Diversity of HIV type 1 and drug resistance mutations among injecting drug users in Kenya AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses. 2013 Jan;29(1):187-90. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Sigaloff KC, Mandaliya K, Hamers RL, Otieno F, Jao IM, Lyagoba F et al. Short communication: High prevalence of transmitted antiretroviral drug resistance among newly HIV type 1 diagnosed adults in Mombasa, Kenya AIDS Research Human Retroviruses. 2012 Sep;28(9):1033-7. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Steegen K, Luchters S, Dauwe K, Reynaerts J, Mandaliya K, Jaoko W et al. Effectiveness of antiretroviral therapy and development of drug resistance in HIV-1 infected patients in Mombasa, Kenya AIDS Research Therapy. 2009 Jun 16;6:12. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Joseph M, Sylvester K, Stephen L, Hannah T, Fanice KJ, Catherine G et al. Integrating Nutrition Support for Food-Insecure Patients and their Dependents Into an HIV Care and Treatment Program in Western Kenya American Journal of Public Health. 2009 Feb;99(2):215-21. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Sampathkumar R, Shadabi E, La D, John Ho, Binhua L, Joshua K et al. Naturally occurring protease inhibitor resistance mutations and their frequencies in HIV proviral sequences of drug-naïve sex workers in Nairobi, Kenya. Retrovirology. 2014; 11(Suppl 1): P133. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Frentz D, Boucher CAB, van de Vijver DAMC. Temporal changes in the epidemiology of transmission of drug-resistant HIV-1 across the world AIDS Rev. Jan-Mar 2012;14(1):17-27. Google Scholar
- Abbott Laboratories. NCDs: Chronic Diseases Affect Us All. Accessed on 20th September 2019.
- Oluwafemi Oguntibeju O. Quality of life of people living with HIV and AIDS and antiretroviral therapy. HIV AIDS (Auckl). 2012;4:117-24. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Moraes DC, Oliveira RC, Costa SF. Adherence of men living with HIV/AIDS to antiretroviral treatment. Anna Nery School Journal of Nursing. 2014;18(4):676-681. Google Scholar
- World Health Organization. Global action plan on HIV drug resistance 2017-2021. Accessed on 20th September 2019.
- Samoel AK, Washington O, Raphael WL, Joyceline K, Joseph M, Joseph M et al. HIV Type 1 Subtypes in Circulation in Northern Kenya. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruse. 2005 Sep;21(9):810-4. PubMed | Google Scholar