Prevalence and factors associated with cancellation and deferment of elective surgical cases at a rural private tertiary hospital in Western Uganda: a cross sectional study
Bienfait Mumbere Vahwere1,&, Franck Katembo Sikakulya1,2, Robinson Ssebuufu1, Soria Jorge1, Xaviour Francis Okedi1, Shaban Abdullah1, Patrick Kyamanywa1
1Department of Surgery, Kampala International University, Kampala, Uganda, 2Faculty of Medicine, Universite Catholique du Graben, Butembo, Democratic Republic of Congo
Bienfait Mumbere Vahwere, Department of Surgery, Kampala International University, Kampala, Uganda
the cancellation of elective surgery is still a worldwide challenge and this is associated with emotional and economical trauma for the patients and their families as well as a decrease in the efficiency of the operating theatre. This study aimed at determining the prevalence and factors associated with cancellation and deferment of elective surgery in a rural private tertiary teaching hospital in Western Uganda.
a cross-sectional study design was conducted. Data was collected from 1st July 2019 to 31st December 2019. Patients scheduled for elective surgery and either cancelled or deferred on the actual day of surgery were included in the study. Statistical analysis was done using STATA version 15.
four hundred patients were scheduled for elective surgery during the study period, among which 90 (22.5%) were cancelled and 310 (78.5%) had their surgeries as scheduled. The highest cancellation of elective surgical operations was observed in general surgery department with 81% elective cases cancelled or deferred, followed by orthopedic department 10% and gynecology department 9%. The most common reasons for cancellation were patient-related (39%) and health worker-related (35%) factors. Other factors included administrative (17%) and anesthesia related factors (9%). Cancellation was mainly due to lack of finances which accounted for 23.3% of the patients, inadequate patient preparation (16.6%) and unavailability of surgeons (15.5%). Major elective surgeries were cancelled 1.7 times more than minor electives surgeries [adjusted prevalence ratio 1.7 (95%CI: 1.07-2.73) and p-value: 0.024].
cancellation and deferment of elective surgeries is still of a major concern in this private rural tertiary hospital with most of the reasons easily preventable through proper scheduling of patients, improved communication between surgical teams and with patients; and effective utilization of available resources and man power.
The cancellation of a scheduled list for elective surgery is still a worldwide challenge . Cancellation of surgery refers to failure to realize a scheduled surgical procedure . Cancellation can be avoidable and non-avoidable and the latter is seen as the commonest in developing countries with a range of 10-45% and 0.37-28% in developed countries . Abrupt cancellation of elective surgery leads to emotional trauma and financial loss for such patients and their families .
The reasons for cancellation of elective surgery are not exhaustive and vary from one hospital to another . Alterations in patients´ medical status and emergency cases are the most common unavoidable causes of cancellation [2,5]. However, inadequate preoperative evaluation, scheduling errors, unavailability of human resources and lack of equipment are the avoidable reasons for late cancellation of patients from the operation list .
The elective case cancellation rate on the day of surgery is an indicator of operating theatre efficiency . Although there is no consensus on the acceptable cut off for case cancellation rates when defining efficient operating theatres, less than 5% is generally recommended [5,6].
In Uganda, studies conducted in the public health sector found that the prevalence of cancellation of elective surgical procedures was between 23.9% to 28.8%, with orthopedic surgery having the highest cancellation rate [7,8]. Two-thirds of the factors causing cancellations were facility-related and more than 50% of all cancellations were potentially avoidable  and yet in rural area especially in private hospitals, data is still limited on cancellation and deferment of elective surgery.
This study focused on cancellation of elective surgeries in a rural tertiary hospital in Western Uganda with the aim of determining the prevalence and contributory factors to cancellation in order to generate strategies to reduce the rate of cancellation of elective surgeries.
Study design: this was a cross sectional study carried out from 1st July 2019 to 31st December 2019 at a rural private tertiary teaching hospital in Western Uganda.
Setting: the study was done in operating theatres of Kampala International University Teaching Hospital (KIU-TH), a private nonprofit teaching hospital located in Bushenyi district in Western Uganda. KIU-TH has a capacity of 400 beds with 5 operating rooms where major and minor surgical procedures are performed. The Department of General Surgery has general surgeons, residents and intern doctors. Three days per week are set aside for elective surgeries (Monday, Wednesday and Friday) while the other days are reserved for booking of patients in the outpatient clinics. Each theatre day has at least 2 surgeons and residents assigned for elective operations. The orthopedic ward has specialist orthopedic surgeons and orthopedic clinical officers and each orthopedic surgeon has a specific day per week for elective bone cases.
The Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology has specialist obstetricians and gynecologists, residents and intern doctors; each gynecologist and a group of residents have a specific day per week for elective surgery and similar organization exists for the Department of Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) and the Dental Department. The Department of Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) has otorhinolaryngologists who are assigned for operation of elective cases on each theatre day and lastly the Dental Department has 2 dental surgeons assigned for elective dental cases on each theatre day. KIU-TH has anesthesiologists and anesthetic officers who also perform the pre-anesthetic assessments of all patients on the definitive theatre list a day prior to surgery.
Participants: all patients scheduled for elective operation constituted our study population. All patients on the theatre list submitted to the theatre team a day prior to the date of operation and were cancelled on the actual day of the operation were included in our study.
Data sources/measurement: the reason of cancellation of the surgery as given by the surgeon and recorded on the hard copy of the theatre list was captured using a structured questionnaire.
The reasons for cancellation were grouped into: anesthesia related, surgeon related, administrative and patient related.
Socio-demographic factors: age, sex, address, highest educational level attained and profession.
Types of surgeries: minor surgery was defined as any invasive operative procedure in which only skin or mucus membranes and connective tissue was incised or resected, with minimal bleeding of less than 500 ml and patient did not require admission after the operation ; Major surgery: was defined as any invasive operative procedure in which a more extensive resection was performed, for example a laparotomy with organs removed, or with normal anatomy altered during which bleeding of more than 500ml was expected and the patient was admitted for at least a day after operation .
Health workers related reasons: transfer to another service: patient needed to be managed by a surgeon of a specific specialty; decision that the patient is not fit for surgery, for example:
i) patient didn´t need an operation but chemotherapy/radiotherapy;
ii) no need for secondary closure because the wound is healing by secondary intention;
iii) patient needed manual reduction and immobilization with a plaster of Paris (POP);
iv) bowel not well-prepared dirty wound and wrong diagnosis.
Surgeon not available; needed further investigation: for example computerizing tomography scan (CT scan), prostatic specific antigen (PSA), liver function tests (LFTs), renal function tests (RFTs), barium enema, cysto-urography (CUG).
Anesthesia related reasons: decision made by the anesthetic team to cancel the surgical procedure. For example, that the patient has high blood pressure, low hemoglobin, patient with acute respiratory infection, patient not adequately starved, inaccessibility of the peripheral vein for administration of drugs and any other condition which can compromise the life of a patient if given anesthesia.
Patient related reasons: financial constraints; patient declined surgery; patient didn´t turn up.
Administrative related reasons: lack of equipment such as feeding tubes, Humby´s knife, breathing system for children; no space for operation: theatre contaminated after a dirty emergency case like gas gangrene, interruption by an emergency operation; lack of oxygen, shortage of blood in the blood bank, lack of sundries or any other drug.
Data processing and analysis plan: data was exported from Excel into STATA version 15 for statistical analysis. Categorical variables were presented using frequencies, percentages and continuous variables were presented using means, standard deviations (SD) and inter-quantile range (IQR). The categorical variables were analyzed using Chi-square and/or t-test for categorical variables and continuous variables respectively, to study associations with cancellation of surgery.
Poisson regression was used for cancelled surgery as the dependent variable and all other variables taken as the independent variables. We did bivariate and multiple regressions and presented crude and adjusted prevalence-rate ratios (a.PR) to estimate the strength of the associations. The prevalence-rate ratios were used on the assumption that the prevalence of cancellation of surgery was common as it was over greater than 15%. All the variables with a p-value of <0.2 in the bivariate analysis were selected for inclusion into the multivariable model analysis.
Ethical approval and consent to participate: this study received approval from the management of Kampala International University Teaching Hospital in Western Uganda. Permission to access records was obtained from the hospital administration of KIU-TH and data was collected anonymously. There was no interaction with patients and patient consent was deemed not necessary. Only statistical data was extracted from the hospital records.
A total number of 94 theatre lists of elective operations from the Department of General Surgery, ENT, Dental, Orthopedic and Gynecology were submitted to the theatre team a day before the scheduled operation in the period under review. The average number of patients per theatre list was 5 (range 1-10) and the total number of patients who were scheduled for surgery which was 400.
The Department of ENT and Dental did not cancel any elective surgery during this study.
Among the 400 patients who were scheduled for surgical operations; the majority 310 (77.5%) were operated while 90 patients (22.5%) were cancelled or deferred. Of the cancelled elective surgeries, pre-anesthetic review was performed on 46.6% of the patients while 54.4% did not get pre-operative assessment.
During our study most of the patients who were cancelled were from surgery department 81% compared to orthopedic (10%) and obstetrics and gynecology (9%) departments (Figure 1).
Socio-demographic characteristics of the study population: from the 400 patients planned for surgery, 103 (25.8%) were aged 20 years and below, 237 (59.2%) between 40 and 60 years and 60 (15.0%). The age mean was 36 years. The majority of patients were male 241 (60.2%). Most of the patients were from rural area 247 (61.8%); most patients were self-employed (peasant farmer) 189 (47.3), followed by unemployed 72 (18.0%), student 72 (18.0%) (Table 1).
Types of surgeries: the minor operation 246 (61.5%) and the major operation 154 (38.5%) with the most common being (Table 2): excision and biopsy 62 (15.5%), debridement 47 (11.8%), laparotomy 20 (5.0%), ORIF 18 (4.5%), OREF 17 (4.3), hemoroidectomy 17 (4.3%) and secondary closure 16 (4.1%) (Table 3).
Factors associated with cancellation/deferring of elective surgery: the current results did not show significant factors associated with the cancellation of elective surgeries at the bivariate analysis level; however, at multivariate level, major elective surgeries were cancelled 1.7 times more cancelled than minor surgeries [adjusted prevalence ratio 1.7 (95%CI: 1.07-2.73) and p-value: 0.024] (Table 4).
Causes of cancellation/deferring of elective surgery: the most common causes of cancellation were patient related (39%), followed by surgeon related reasons (35%) and administrative issues (17%) (Figure 2). Among the patient related factors, the most common were the financial issues (23.3%), unavailability of the surgeon 15.5% and unfitness for surgery (14.4%) were the most common health worker related reasons for cancellation of elective surgery in this study (Table 5).
During the period under review (July 2019 - December 2019), 400 surgical interventions were planned, of which 90 (22.5%) were cancelled. Despite the fact that there is no acceptable range of cancellation, less than 5% is generally recommended , Although our findings are higher than the recommended range, they are within the range observed in other developing countries, which is between 10-45% [8,10-13]. The prevalence of cancellation in developed countries is reported to be between 0.37-28% [14,15].
In this study, the Department of General Surgery had the highest percentage of cancellation (81%), followed by orthopedics (10%) and gynecology 9% departments.
This is different from the results published by Desta et al. in Ethiopia where cancellation of orthopedic cases was more prevalent (28.7%) followed by general surgery (17.8%) and gynecology (15.1%) . In Tanzania, general surgery had the highest cancellation rate (31.5%) followed by orthopedics (25.5%)  which was different from what was found in Saudi Arabia  where orthopedics department was found to have the highest prevalence of cancellation at 33.9% and in Finland (31.8%)  of orthopedics cases among elective surgeries. However, Lonkoandea et al. found that the majority of cancelled surgeries were general surgery (80.4%), gynecology (11.7%) .
The age group 41-60, with a mean age of 36.7 (SD) years was the commonest among the participants in this study. This is different to studies done in Uganda and Sri Lanka in which the age groups of 10-19 years, 164 (41.0%) and 61-70 years (31.1%) were associated with more cancellations, respectively [8,18]. Pre-operative assessment a day before surgery might be the explanation behind this difference between studies.
In this study, the surgeries were grouped into minor operations 246 (61.5%) and major operations 154 (38.5%). These results are in line with those found by Hewawasam in Sri Lanka where the cancellations of major, intermediate and minor surgeries were 58.5%, 18.9%, 22.6% respectively . In addition, major surgeries were more cancelled than minor surgeries, in this study. Proper assessment is needed prior to any surgery to avoid late cancellation which has an impact on socioeconomic aspects of surgical patients. However, much attention should be given to assessment of patients undergoing major surgery at least a day prior to operation.
The causes of cancellation among elective surgery were 39%, 35%, 17% and 9% for patient, surgeon, administration and anesthesia related reasons respectively. The results of this current study are similar to those found by Desta et al. in Ethiopia, which revealed that patient-related factors were a common reason for the cancellation of elective surgical cases accounting for 30% of cancellations  and Ezike et al. found in Nigeria found that the unavailability of the surgeon as the most common cause of cancelation at 35.8% . However, our results of this study are different from the findings by Jonnalagadda et al. in a tertiary public teaching hospital in the Caribbean island of Barbados, who identified a number of administrative and infrastructural hindrances to the timely performance of elective surgical procedures . This was also the case in another study carried out in Uganda by Ogwal et al. which revealed the cancellations mostly being inclined to health facility reasons (68.8%) and health care workers issues in (24.35%) .
In our study, the financial constraints contributed to the largest number of cancellations (23.3%) followed by unfitness of the patient to surgery (16.6%) while 15.5% was as a result of unavailability of the senior surgeon. The results are similar to those reported by Kaddoum et al. where the financial constraints were the most single cause of cancellation followed by incomplete medical work up . Our findings are also similar to findings in Mulago Hospital in Uganda where the causes for the delay to surgery included lack of theatre space 44 (33.1%) cases, lack of blood to use in perioperative time 40 (30.1%) and patient related factors . In a private hospital in Tanzania, it was found that the rate of cancellation of elective surgeries due financial issues was low (6.3%)  compared to findings in our study and this can be explained in part by the availability of the health assurance in Tanzania.
Analysis of a government facility in central Uganda discovered that less than 5% of patients could access necessary surgical care without incurring catastrophic out-of-pocket expenditure . Accessing surgical care in developing countries represent a substantial economic burden to a majority of the population [7,10].
Among the 90 cancelled cases only 46.6% benefited from pre-anesthetic assessment while 54.4% didn´t benefit from it. This rate is higher than that found in a study done in Burkina Faso by Lonkoandea et al. where pre-anesthetic assessment was not carried out for 7% of the patients who underwent the elective surgeries . Earlier pre-anesthetic assessment of the surgical patient can allow more time to correct observed abnormal laboratory investigation results and to improve some uncontrolled medical conditions and therefore reduce cancellation rate [21,22]. Pre-admission anesthetic consultations at these clinics could not only improve efficiency of theatre use but also reduce the duration of hospital stay and hospital costs [21,22].
During data collection of this study, a follow up of all prospective theatre lists was done by assigning a research assistant to review the lists before submission to the theatre team to avoid bias of selection and result; however, this study was not evaluating the financial income of the patient during data collection which could have informed the relationship between cancellation of elective surgeries and level of financial income.
The cancellation of elective surgeries is still high in our setting. Most cancellations were avoidable and therefore there is a need for more audits to mitigate this issue. In order to enhance cost effectiveness and efficiency, efforts should be made to prevent unnecessary postponement through careful planning aimed at proper scheduling, pre-anesthetic evaluation and perioperative preparation, provide adequate information for the scheduled patient, providing necessary operating room equipment by hospital administrators and other stakeholders and clear communication with operating room team. We suggest for future research on cancellation of elective surgeries should compare private and public health facilities and analyze the role of health financing mechanisms.
What is known about this topic
- The cancellation of elective operations on the intended day and its effect in the urban health setting;
- Most studies on cancellation are done in public hospitals where the government bear the cost of the operations.
What this study adds
- This study is adding data about the prevalence and causes of cancellations in the rural private health setting;
- This study is highlighting the deer need of introducing of health assurance for all Ugandans;
- Quality improvement strategies to be designed to improve on communication between health workers, patients and administration and also pre-anesthetic assessment to be done as a must.
The authors declare no competing interests.
BMV and FKS, RS conceived and designed the survey; supervised data collection and critically reviewed the manuscript; SJ, SA and XFO supervised data collection and PK critically reviewed the manuscript. All the authors have read and agreed to the final manuscript.
Authors thank the management of Kampala International University Teaching Hospital for allowing them to carry out this study and all staff for their cooperation during data collection. We thank Mr. Yusufu Mulumba the statician for the analysis of the data in this study.
Tables and figures
Table 1: socio-demographic characteristics of the study population
Table 2: types of surgeries and cancellation of elective surgeries
Table 3: diversity of surgeries and cancellation of elective surgeries
Table 4: bivariate and multivariate poisson regression analysis of cancellation of surgery with social demographic characteristics and other selected variables of the respondents
Table 5: distribution of reasons of cancelled surgeries at Kampala International University Teaching Hospital, 2019
Figure 1: cases cancelled among elective surgery in each department at Kampala International University Teaching Hospital, June-December, 2019
Figure 2: reasons of cancellation of elective surgeries in categories
- Abeeleh MA, Tareef TM, Hani AB, Albsoul N, Samarah OQ, ElMohtaseb MS et al. Reasons for operation cancellations at a teaching hospital: prioritizing areas of improvement. Ann Surg Treat Res. 2017;93(2):65-9. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Desta M, Manaye A, Tefera A, Worku A, Wale A, Mebrat A et al. Incidence and causes of cancellations of elective operation on the intended day of surgery at a tertiary referral academicmedical center in Ethiopia. Patient Saf Surg. 2018;12:25. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Mulira M, Smith MD, Moorman J. Factors contributing to elective theatre cancellations in the department of surgery at Chbah. South African Journal of Surgery. 2017;55(2):66-7. Google Scholar
- Elrahman AA, Hamza AA, El-Ha MA. Cancellation of elective general surgical operations at the day of intended surgery. Glob J Med Res. 2014.
- Kaddoum R, Fadlallah R, Hitti V, Jardali FE, Eid GE. Causes of cancellations on the day of surgery at a Tertiary Teaching Hospital. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016;16:259. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Chiu CH, Lee A, Chui PT. Cancellation of elective operations on the day of intended surgery in a Hong Kong hospital: point prevalence and reasons. Hong Kong Med J. 2012 Feb;18(1):5-10. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Jonnalagadda R, Walrond ER, Hariharan S, Walrond M, Prasad C. Evaluation of the reasons for cancellations and delays of surgical procedures in a developing country. Int J Clin Pract. 2005;59(6):716-720. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Ogwal A, Oyania F, Nkonge E, Makumbi T, Galukande M. Prevalence and predictors of cancellation of elective surgical procedures at a Tertiary Hospital in Uganda: a cross-sectional study, Hindawi. Surg Res Pract. 2020 Mar 19;2020:1464098. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Routine preoperative lab test guidelines for adult patients (≥ 16 years) undergoing elective surgery. 2016. Accessed on May 10th 2020.
- Rajaguru PP, Jusabani MA, Massawe H, Temu R, Sheth NP. Understanding surgical care delivery in sub-Saharan Africa: a cross-sectional analysis of surgical volume, operations, and financing at a tertiary referral hospital in rural Tanzania. Glob Health Res Policy. 2019;4:30. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Chalya PL, Gilyoma JM, Mabula JB, Simbila S, Ngayomela IH, Chandika AB et al. Incidence, causes and pattern of cancellation of elective surgical operations in a University Teaching Hospital in the Lake Zone, Tanzania. Afr Health Sci. 2011 Sep;11(3):438-43. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Bhuiyan MZU, Mavhungu R, Machowski A. Provision of an emergency theatre in tertiary hospitals is cost-effective: audit and cost of cancelled planned elective general surgical operations at Pietersburg Hospital, Limpopo Province, South Africa. S Afr Med J. 2017;107(3):239-242. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Lonkoandea M, Bonkoungou P, Traore S, Kabore R, Ouangre E, Pendeville P. Cancellation of elective surgical procedures in the university teaching hospital center Yalgado Ouedraogo in Burkina Faso: incidence, reasons and proposals for improvement. Southern African Journal of Anaesthesia and Analgesia. 2016;22(5):140-144. Google Scholar
- Mesmar M, Shatnawi NJ, Faori I, Khader YS. Reasons for cancellation of elective operations at a major teaching referral hospital in Jordan. East Mediterr Health J. 2011 Aug;17(8):651-5. PubMed | Google Scholar
- El-Dawlatly A, Turkistani A, Aldohayan A, Zubaidi A, Ahmed A. Reasons of cancellation of elective surgery in a teaching hospital. Int J Anesthesiol. 2008;15:2.
- Laisi J, Tohmo H, Keränen U. Surgery cancelation on the day of surgery in same-day admission in a Finnish hospital. Scand J Surg. 2013;102(3):204-8. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Ezike H, Ajuzieogu V, Amucheazi A. Reasons for elective surgery cancellation in a referral hospital. Ann Med Health Sci Res. 2011;1(2):197-202. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Hewawasam GC, Maduwanth A. Cancellation of elective surgical procedures in the Genito-Urinary section of National Hospital of Sri Lanka - can we do better. Sri Lankan Journals Online. 2013. Google Scholar
- Kajja S, Sibinga S. Delayed elective surgery in a major teaching hospital in Uganda. International Journal of Clinical Transfusion Medicine. 2014:2:1-6. Google Scholar
- Lee A, Kerridge RK, Chui PT, Chiu CH, Gin T. Perioperative systems as a quality model of perioperative medicine and surgical care. Health Policy. 2011;102(2-3):214-22. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Anderson GA, Ilcisin L, Kayima P, Abesiga L, Portal Benitez N, Ngonzi J et al. Out-of-pocket payment for surgery in Uganda: the rate of impoverishing and catastrophic expenditure at a government hospital. PLoS ONE. 2017;12(10):e0187293. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Ebirim LN, Buowari DY, Ezike HA. Causes of cancellation of elective surgical operations at a University Teaching Hospital. J Med Med Sci. 2012;3(5):297-301.