Breast cancer patientsí presentation for oncological treatment: a single centre study
Breast cancer patientsí presentation for oncological treatment: a single centre study
Akinbolaji Andrew Akinkuolie1,&, Amarachukwu Chiduziem Etonyeaku1, Olalekan Olasehinde1, Olukayode Adeolu Arowolo1, Rereloluwa Nicodemus Babalola2
1Department of Surgery, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria, 2Department of Surgery, Obafemi Awolowo University, Teaching Hospitals Complex Ile-Ife, Nigeria
Akinbolaji Andrew Akinkuolie, Department of Surgery, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria
Introduction: breast cancer patients are presenting at advanced stages for oncological treatment in Nigeria and World Health Organization predicted developing countries incidence and mortality to increase by year 2020.
Methods: prospective observational hospital based study that enrolled breast cancer patients from catchment area of an oncology service hospital in Nigeria between 2007 and 2013. Patientsí demographics, breast cancer burden and care giver presentation variables were analysed for causal factors of seeking medical help and what determines commencement of effective oncological treatment.
Results: forty-six patients were enrolled, 19.6% of them presented primarily to oncologist while 80.4% presented secondarily for oncological treatment. There is a significant difference in presentation time for oncological treatment (t = -3.56, df = 42.90, p = 0.001) between primary (M =11.56 Ī 5.21 weeks) and secondary presentation (M= 52.56 Ī 10.27weeks) . Tumor burden of those that presented secondarily were significantly more advanced (U = 78.5, p = 0.011) and, univariate analysis reveals that: patientsí matrimonial setting, breast cancer awareness and mode of discovery of breast symptoms are patient related factors that determines their choice of caregiver presentation and, determinant of effective oncological treatment is patient first contact care provider.
Conclusion: patientsí bio-characteristics that determine their choice of health care provider should be incorporated into community breast cancer sensitization drives. Additionally, there is a need for a government agency assign the task of accrediting and defining scope of enterprise of health care institutions and their care providers in our pluralist health system.
Breast cancer is the commonest cancer among women worldwide and the most common cause of cancer related morbidity and mortality [1-3]. There is marked geographical variation in morbidity and mortality of breast cancer between the developed and developing countries [4-7]. Breast cancer screening and early presentation has changed the dismal outcome of this disease in the developed countries where despite increasing incidence, the morbidity and mortality are declining [4, 8]. However, the contrary is true in developing countries especially Nigeria where despite alarming increase in incidence, about 70 - 80% of breast cancer patients are still presenting with locally advanced or metastatic breast cancer [9-12]. More worrisome is the World Health Organization (WHO) report that expects world breast cancer incidence and mortality to increase by 50% by 2020 and this increase is anticipated to be highest in the developing countries of which Nigeria is inclusive: where 55% increase in incidence and 58% increase in mortality is predicted [13, 14]. In preparing for this anticipated increase, priority in developing countries should be to formulate breast cancer control strategies such as early breast cancer detection and early presentation for effective oncological treatment [15, 16] . The objective of this study is to find out patientsí related factors promoting early presentation and causal factor(s) of effective oncological treatment with the aim of reducing breast cancer related morbidity and mortality.
This is a cross-sectional hospital based study carried out at Wesley Guild Hospital (WGH) in Ilesa, between January 2007 and December 2013. Ilesa is a cosmopolitan town situated in Osun States in south western Nigeria. The town has good roads network connection and transport system, it health system is pluralist made up of orthodox and modern health facilities and the modern health facilities consist of private and government owned hospitals. WGH is one of the governments owned hospital and is a satellite hospital of Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex (OAUTHC), Ile-Ife, Nigeria. Eligibility for the study is being a breast cancer patient presenting at the surgical oncology unit of WGH consenting to recruitment and data collected to be used for research purpose. Inclusion criteria were: being domicile in Ilesha and malignant breast lesion. Exclusion criteria were: being domicile outside Ilesha, benign breast lesion and inability to provide adequate information because of karnofsky performance status. Data obtained were patientsí demographics, clinical and laboratory details of breast cancer burden using American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system and evolution of patientís presentation to health care provider(s). Patients were subdivided into two groups whether they presenting primarily or secondarily for oncological treatment Data obtained were entered into the proforma designed for the study and analysed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences version 22. Descriptive statistics were employed for univariate analysis and, independent samples t test, nonparametric tests and regression analysis for multivariate analysis.
Forty-six patients met the inclusion criteria. They were all females; nine of these patients presented primarily in WGH while the remaining 37 presented secondarily for oncological treatment. Details of their demographic bio- characteristics are as shown in Figure 1 and Table 1. Patient first contact with health care provider distribution (Figure 2) reveals that 60.9% of the sum total of patients presented primarily either at herbal or private hospital. The mean presentation time in weeks for oncological treatment (Figure 3) was longest - 89 weeks - in patients from herbal home and the tumour burden was much advanced (Figure 4) in patients from herbal home and private hospitals. There is a significant difference in presentation time between those that presented primarily (M =11.56 Ī 5.21 weeks) and those that presented secondarily (M = 52.56 Ī 10.27weeks ) for oncological treatment: ( t = -3.56, df = 42.90, two tailed p = 0.001). There is also significant difference in tumour burden between those that presented primarily and those that presented secondarily (U = 78.5, p = 0.011). Table 2 shows care providersí documentation of patientsí disease., None of the patients from herbal home and mission house had any documentation of their disease and only about half of patients from private hospitals had documentation. In multivariate analysis significant patientsí related factors promoting early presentation to their choice of health care provider (Table 3) are: their matrimonial setting, breast cancer awareness and mode of discovery of breast symptoms and, the significant determinant whether a breast cancer patient will have effective oncological treatment is their first healthcare provider (Table 4).
Presentation of breast cancer patients at advanced stage is a major contributor to increasing morbidity and mortality in the developing countries [14, 17]. Reviews from other developing countries (Table 5) highlight reasons for advanced stage presentation from various nations. The variations of causes from nation to nation may be related to their socio-cultural background [18, 19]; therefore, it is important to know the genesis of advanced stage presentation in our environment so as to incorporate this into future breast cancer campaign. Outcome of this study reveals that 19.6% of the patients presented directly in an institution where they had access to oncological treatment while the remaining 80.4% presented primarily at centres with limited resources for breast cancer management with significant difference in the disease burden and presentation time in the two categories of patients. Though, matrimonial setting, breast cancer awareness and mode of discovery of breast symptoms are prominent patientsí related factors promoting early presentation to their primary care giver; the relative importance these factors may be complex and interrelated. The role of matrimonial setting in the choice of care provider presentation may be related to family belief about breast cancer , treaty with a family doctor/spiritualist, and previous family experience of poor outcome of close relatives with breast cancer treated at modern health facility . Though, it is commonly argued that the final health related decision rested with the patient but in African context it is a taboo for a woman to disobey her spouse or close relative even at the risk of her health. Therefore, campaigns directed at early breast cancer presentation should not only be aimed at patients but also at her family. Breast cancer awareness and mode of discovery of breast symptoms as determinants of care provider presentation reflect patient knowledge of the disease and the disease outcome . Surprisingly, breast cancer patientís level of education is not a determinant of her early presentation to a care provider in this study (Table 3); probably academic certification may not be synonymous with awareness of a disease and where to obtain appropriate treatment . Thus literacy may not necessarily infer knowledge of a disease and this should be considered during breast cancer sensitization drives.
†The result of this study shows the dominant role of health care provider at first patients’ contact as determinant of effective oncological treatment, though being tag qualified health care personnel is at the prerogative of the government who is the licensing body; unfortunately, 80.4% of the patients presented outside the setting where they can access oncological management. The care providersí documentation of patientsí disease in Table 2 may be from misdiagnosis , lack of knowledge of the disease and available treatment options . Additionally, it may be from poor judgement about the need for referral to the appropriate caregiver [26, 27]. Improvement in breast cancer outcome in our society can still be accomplished within the existing pluralist health care system through practical interventions that are realistic and efficient [17, 21]. The goal of future research will be to find out what implementation strategies can most effectively guide our pluralist health system reorganization to improve breast cancer outcome. In this regard, there is need for evaluation of appropriate certification and re -accreditation of health care institutions and their permissible scope of enterprise on breast cancer outcome and the effect of disease recognition training in oncology for caregivers operating herbal and convalescence homes on breast cancer presentation. Additionally, there is urgent need for upgrading existing government health care infrastructures and training of personnel in oncology to cope with oncological challenges of years to come.
Presentation of breast cancer patients outside the setting where they can access early and effective oncological treatment seems to forms the basis of advanced stage presentation. Matrimonial setting, breast cancer awareness and mode of discovery of breast symptoms are significant patientsí bio-characteristics that determine their choice of health care provider. These factors should be considered in community breast cancer sensitization drives. Additionally, non oncologist health care providers in our pluralist health system will need re-training in oncology and their scope of enterprise should be properly defined by appropriate government institution.
What is known about this topic
What this study adds
The authors declare no competing interest.
Akinbolaji Andrew AKINKUOLIE was involved in conceptualization, design, data acquisition, and literature search, definition of intellectual content, statistical analysis, preparation, editing and review of the manuscript. Amarachukwu Chiduziem ETONYEAKU participated in conceptualization, design, data acquisition, and literature search, definition of intellectual content, statistical analysis, preparation, editing and review of the manuscript. Olalekan OLASEHINDE took part in conceptualization, design, data acquisition, and literature search, definition of intellectual content, preparation, editing and review of the manuscript. Olukayode Adeolu AROWOLO played a part in data acquisition, and literature search, definition of intellectual content, preparation, editing and review of the manuscript. Rereloluwa Nicodemus BABALOLA contributed in data acquisition, and literature search, definition of intellectual content, preparation and editing of the manuscript. All the authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
Table 1: patientsí demographic bio-characteristics
Table 2: care providersí documentation of patientsí disease
Table 3: determinants of patientsí early presentation to care providers
Table 4: determinants of effective oncological treatment
Table 5: reviews of presentation of breast cancer patients from developing countries
Figure 1: summary of enrolled patients
Figure 2: patientís distribution at first care providerís contact
Figure 3: patientsí first care providers and mean duration of symptoms before oncological treatment
Figure 4: distribution of patientsí AJCC staging at first oncological treatment
|The Pan African Medical Journal articles are archived on Pubmed Central. Access PAMJ archives on PMC here|
Volume 26 (Jan - Apr 2017)
This article authors
|On Google Scholar|
Navigate this article
Tables and figures
|Table 1: patients´ demographic bio-characteristics|
|Table 2: care providers´ documentation of patients´ disease|
|Table 3: determinants of patients´ early presentation to care providers|
|Table 4: determinants of effective oncological treatment|
|Table 5: reviews of presentation of breast cancer patients from developing countries|
|Figure 1: summary of enrolled patients|
|Figure 2: patient´s distribution at first care provider´s contact|
|Figure 3: patients´ first care providers and mean duration of symptoms before oncological treatment|
|Figure 4: distribution of patients´ AJCC staging at first oncological treatment|
Rate this article
Popular articles in Research
|1||Impact de la varicocèle sur le volume testiculaire et les paramètres spermatiques|
|2||Assessment of renal function and electrolytes in patients with thyroid dysfunction in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: a cross sectional study|
|3||Implementation challenges of free maternity services policy in Kenya: the health workersí perspective|
|4||Prevalence and characteristics of prostate cancer among participants of a community-based screening in Nigeria using serum prostate specific antigen and digital rectal examination|
|5||Profil épidémiologique et clinique de la tuberculose dans la zone de santé de Lubumbashi (RD Congo)|
|6||Immunization coverage and its determinants among children aged 12 - 23 months in a peri-urban area of Kenya|
|7||Pan African Medical Journal (Pamj) and African Field Epidemiology Network (AFENET): A partnership for the future of medical publishing in Africa|