Profiling lifetime episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding among patients from rural Sub-Saharan Africa where schistosoma mansoni is endemic
Profiling lifetime episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding among patients from rural Sub-Saharan Africa where schistosoma mansoni is endemic
Christopher Kenneth Opio1,&, Francis Kazibwe2, Ponsiano Ocama1, Lalitha Rejani1, Elena Nikolaevna Belousova3, Paul Ajal4
1Makerere University, College of Health Sciences, P.O.Box 7072, Kampala, Uganda, 2Bishop Stuart University, Public Health Department, P.O.Box 9, Mbarara, Uganda, 3Kazan University, Russian Federation, 4Pakwach Health Centre IV, Ministry of Health, Pakwach, Uganda
Christopher Kenneth Opio, Senior Lecturer, Department of Medicine, Makerere University College of Health Sciences, P.O. Box 7072, Kampala, Uganda
Introduction: severe severe chronic hepatic schistosomiasis is a common cause of episodes upper gastrointestinal bleeding (UGIB) in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). However, there is paucity of data on clinical epidemiology of episodes of UGIB from rural Africa despite on going public health interventions to control and eliminate schistosomiasis.
Methods: through through a cross sectional study we profiled lifetime episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding and associated factors at a rural primary health facility in sub-Saharan Africa were schistosomiasis is endemic. The main outcome was number of lifetime episodes of UGIB analyzed as count data.
Results: from from 107 enrolled participants, 323 lifetime episodes of UGIB were reported. Fifty-seven percent experienced ≥ 2 lifetime episodes of UGIB. Ninety-four percent had severe chronic hepatic schistosomiasis and 80% esophageal varices. Alcohol use and viral hepatitis was infrequent. Eighty-eight percent were previously treated with praziquantel and 70% had a history of blood transfusion. No patient had ever had an endoscopy or treatment for prevention of recurrent variceal bleeding. Multivariable analysis identified a cluster of eight clinical factor variables (age ≥ 40, female sex, history of blood transfusion, abdominal collaterals, esophageal varices, pattern x periportal fibrosis, anemia, and thrombocytopenia) significantly associated (P-value < 0.05) with increased probability of experiencing two or more lifetime episodes of UGIB in our study.
Conclusion: upper gastrointestinal bleeding is a common health problem in this part of rural SSA where schistosomiasis is endemic. The clinical profile described is unique and is important for improved case management, and for future research.
Upper gastrointestinal bleeding (UGIB) is a common worldwide health problem associated with substantial health care cost, morbidity, and death [1-4]. Patients with UGIB may experience one or more lifetime episodes of UGIB. Each new episode of UGIB increases one’s risk of morbidity and death. Among the causes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding, variceal upper gastrointestinal bleeding or UGIB due malignancy have the highest mortality . Variceal upper gastrointestinal bleeding, a complication of portal hypertension is the most frequent type of upper gastrointestinal bleeding in sub Saharan Africa [6-9]. The usual causes of portal hypertension include schistosomiasis mansoni (through periportal fibrosis) and liver cirrhosis (due to chronic viral hepatitis, alcoholic liver disease, and others) [10-13]. In the absence of treatment up to 50% with severe chronic hepatic schistosomiasis of Mansoni type and/or chronic viral hepatitis will develop esophageal varices and more than half will experience upper gastrointestinal bleeding during their lifetime. In liver cirrhosis, 4 of 10 that develop acute variceal UGIB will die at 6 weeks, one-third re-bleed thereafter, and only one-third survive beyond 1 year [11,14]. The outcome is much better in UGIB due to schistosomiasis. In this group, 50 to 70% of those who experience their first episode of UGIB will go on to experience more episodes of bleeding over 5 years and one-third will die as a result of bleeding during the same period [15–20]. However, treatment of varices with drugs, bands, and shunts is shown to prevent further episodes of UGIB [21-23]. On the other hand, there is paucity of data on clinical epidemiology of lifetime episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding from rural Africa where schistosomiasis is endemic. We studied patients with one or more episodes of UGIB and determined the factors associated with number of lifetime events among patients presenting at a rural primary health facility in sub Saharan Africa. Our specific study objective was to determine the clinical, laboratory and ultrasound findings associated with increased probability of experiencing two or more episodes of UGIB is this part of rural SSA.
This was routine cross sectional study that involved human participants. It was approved by School of Medicine, Makerere University, Institutional review board, Kampala, Uganda (#REC REF2011-244), and the Uganda National Council for Science and Technology, Kampala, Uganda (UNCST approval #, HS 1620). The study was conducted according to the principles expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki. Written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
Study site and study population This was a cross sectional descriptive and analytic study among patients reporting at least one life time episode of UGIB, aged 12 years and above who presented at Pakwach Health Centre IV over the study period 14th July to 30th august 2014. Pakwach Health Centre IV is located in rural Uganda at banks of the Albert Nile River. The prevalence of schistosomiasis due to S. mansoni in this region is reported at over 50% and facility records report a relatively high frequency of patients with UGIB. Generally, 30 patients above the age of 5 years are seen at outpatients daily and about 4 to 5 adult patients, not including pregnant women are admitted every day. Data from the Uganda national health management information systems for the year 2012/13 recorded 24,222 outpatient visits and 5532 inpatient admissions.
Sample size estimation
Sample size for this cross sectional study design was estimated at 102 participants (n) using a power (a) of 90%, p=15%, N= 285, d= 5% using the formula, n = [(N p (1-p)]/ [(d2/Z21-a/2*(N-1)+p*(1-p)]. Where p is the proportion of patients estimated to develop upper gastrointestinal bleeding due to varices, N is the number patients from this health facility meeting our inclusion criteria in a year, Z is the Z-score, and d is the confidence limits.
Enrolment procedures and data collection
Screening and enrolment were carried during the working week. Patients receiving care at the outpatients and in patient departments at Pakwach health Centre IV were assessed for eligibility. The inclusion criteria comprised aged 12 years and above, written informed consent /assent, and reporting at least one lifetime episode of UGIB. Participants with any absolute or relative contraindication to un-sedated diagnostic upper gastrointestinal endoscopy were excluded from the study. These comprised pregnant women, patients requiring or under resuscitation, and those unable to tolerate the procedure. During screening we employed systematic sampling at outpatients (skipped the first three registered patients and approached every other patient aged 12 years and over) and for ethical reasons recruited all eligible inpatients with acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding (AUGIB) after resuscitation and stabilization during the study period since they would benefit from endoscopy. In the study, UGIB was defined as a lifetime of any of the following: hematemesis and melena or blood in stool as reported by the eligible study participant. However, the main outcome for this study was number of lifetime episodes of UGIB reported by a participant. We recorded socio-demographic data, exposure to schistosoma species or alcohol, treatment of schistosomiasis and time from the last treatment, history of UGIB, related past medical, or drug treatment history, stigmata of chronic liver disease, vital signs, 3-part hematology indices (using compact Sysmex KX-21 hematology analyzer), hepatitis B and C viral blood serology results (obtained by commercially available rapid diagnostic test kits), malaria antigen test results (by rapid diagnostic test kits), stool microscopy for ova, urine circulating cathodic antigen (CCA) test by Rapid diagnostics, and ultrasound findings performed by a trained sonographer according to the modified World Health Organization Niamey protocol. Trans-abdominal ultrasound was performed using the SONOSTAR model SS8, portable ultrasound with a 3.5 MHz convex probe. All participants were then scheduled for diagnostic upper digestive endoscopy that was performed using Pentax EPKi digital video processor and Pentax 9.8 mm video gastroscope for diagnosis. At the commencement of the procedure the patient was gowned, he or she was asked to sit on the procedure bed and xylocaine oral spray administered. He or she was then positioned in the left lateral position and a mouth gag inserted. The oesophagus, stomach, and duodenum were examined for evidence suggestive of UGIB or cause of UGIB with special emphasis on varices, oesophageal or gastric erosions or ulcers. Endoscopic findings were assessed and reported as recommended by the Japanese Research For Portal Hypertension  and /or the modified Forrest classification upper gastrointestinal bleeding  in the clinical report form.
Data management and analysis
Data obtained from these study procedures was recorded into a clinical report form and transcribed into Microsoft Access database software 2007 (Microsoft corporation) on a daily basis. This was later edited to ensure quality and exported to Stata version 13 (STATACorp, Lakeway, College Station, Texas, USA). Within Stata, descriptive and inferential statistics were undertaken profiling the study population and factors associated with episodes of UGIB. Contingency tables summarizing the factor variables relative to the outcome were generated and inference determined by likelihood ratio Chi-square test. Further statistical inference was determined by negative binomial multivariate analysis of the count data with robust estimator of variance. A significance level (p-value < 0.05) was considered, confidence intervals supported inference, and beta coefficients provided a measure of how strongly each factor variable influenced the outcome variable. Selection of the best-fit models was criterion based. Results of the best-fit model (the model with the lowest Akaike information criterion-AIC, and Bayesian information criterion-BIC) were then subject to marginal analysis and which are summarized as a graph. These results are presented in the body of the manuscript, as tables, and as figures.
Over a period of 6 weeks (July 2014 to August 2014), one hundred and seven participants were enrolled. With exception of one participant that reported once a week contact with the waters of the Nile, all other reported 5-7 times a week contacts with the waters of the Nile. Twenty-three were in patients with acute severe UGIB, and 84 outpatients with a past history of UGIB. The prevalence of UGIB among screened at outpatients was 24%; 95%CI (20%-29%). The age range of participants was 25 to 71 years. Sixty percent were females and 96% reported ever experiencing hematemesis. The rest reported melena or hematochesia without hematemesis. The total number of episodes of UGIB reported in the study was 323 episodes. Sixty-one (57%) participants experienced two or more episodes of UGIB during their lifetime and the rest reported experiencing only one episode of UGIB during their lifetime. Seventy-five percent of the study participants experienced their first episode of UGIB within 5 years of enrollment. Ninety-six percent were ever admitted for UGIB, no participant had ever had an endoscopy for their UGIB and 73% previously received blood transfusion for UGIB. Severe chronic hepatic schistosomiasis was diagnosed with certainty in 101 (94%) participants, however alcohol use, serological markers of chronic viral hepatitis, and active infection with schistosoma mansoni were not that frequent. Notably, 78% of our study participants had received praziquantel for treatment of schistosomiasis in the last 12 months. With exception of splenomegaly that was found among 92(90%) participants, stigmata of chronic liver disease were not frequent in our study. More than 50% of our participants had anemia (hemoglobin level< 110g/L) and thrombocytopenia (platelet count < 150x109/L). Esophageal varices were the most common endoscopic finding explaining UGIB and these was found among 80% of our study participants (Table 1).
Clinical factor variables by number of lifetime episodes of UGIB
The frequencies of lifetime episodes of UGIB among the 3 different categories of bleeding “1 episode”, “2 or 3 episodes”, “4 or more episodes”, were 46, 81, and 196 respectively. Participants who experienced more than one episode of UGIB were likely to have the following; aged =40 years, females, severe acute variceal bleeding, history of variceal bleeding, previous treatment with praziquantel, an enlarged spleen, ascites, abdominal collaterals, pattern X according to Niamey protocol, hemoglobin level =90g/L, platelet count = 35 x109/L cells, and esophageal varices at endoscopy. In contrast, participants with one episode of UGIB were likely to have a liver flap and a positive hepatitis B surface antigen test (Table 2).
Multivariable analysis output for the three best-fit models
We identified 3-fit models. Model-3 performed best since it demonstrated the lowest Akaike information criterion and Bayesian information criterion. Model-3 (n=68) included all the factor variables listed and limited to patients who received praziquantel in the last one year. In contrast, model-1 (n=88) included one-year treatment with praziquantel as a factor variable and model-2 (n=105) included all participants not correcting for treatment with praziquantel (Table 3). A summary of the regression coefficients, their standard errors, constants, p-values, and criterion are presented (Table 3).
Impact of factor variables on the number of lifetime episodes of UGIB for model-3
Average marginal effects were calculated from model-3 and presented as a graph, describing the positive impact of the various factor variables on the number of lifetime episodes of UGIB reported by our study participants (Figure 1). On average the presence of any of these factors variables in a participant would increase the individuals probability of experiencing two or more l lifetime episodes of UGIB (Figure 1).
Upper gastrointestinal bleeding is poorly described at primary health care facilities in rural Africa because weak health systems[26–28]. We studied at episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleed as reported by the patients to describe upper gastrointestinal bleeding at a rural primary health care facility. We found upper gastrointestinal bleeding was a common health problem at this primary health facility in rural sub Saharan Africa most participants reported more than 2 lifetime episodes of UGIB. Patient reported upper gastrointestinal bleeding was corroborated by endoscopy, abdominal ultrasound, and presence of anemia[29–31]. Endoscopy and ultrasound showed most participants had esophageal varices and/or meet the ultrasound criteria diagnostic of hepatic schistosomiasis. Moreover, similar findings have been reported by hospital-based studies from the same region[8,9,13,17,32]. In contrast, there was limited evidence to suggest UGIB in our study was mainly due to cirrhosis due to hepatitis or peptic ulcer disease. The study also identified a cluster of factor variables, which were associated with an increased probability of experiencing two or more episodes of UGIB in this population. We found an association between age =40years and number of episodes of UGIB. Others showed individuals aged over 35 years with schistosomiasis had the highest frequency of periportal fibrosis  and were 2 times more likely to develop UGIB . We also found an association between female gender and likelihood of experiencing increasing episodes of UGIB. One study reported females are more likely to present with UGIB due to varices than males . However, we do not have any clear explanation for this peculiar finding. A history of blood transfusion was one of the other factors associated with increasing episodes of UGIB. A number of studies show blood transfusion is associated with recurrent episodes of UGIB [36, 37]. It could be argued that each bleeding episode was a trigger for blood transfusion and since our patients were able to survive this long, the association that we are observing is just an accumulation of several events. On the other hand, some clinical trials show restricting blood transfusion among patients with UGIB was shown to reduce UGIB recurrences and mortality [37,38]. Periportal fibrosis, abdominal collaterals, esophageal varices, anemia, and thrombocytopenia are recognized causes or sequel of portal hypertension. All these factors have been associated with recurrent UGIB. Our findings are comparable with what has been reported by others [12,20,39–43]. The negative correlation of hepatitis B surface antigen or liver flap with increasing number of lifetime episodes of UGIB suggests patients with these factors may not have survived. This explanation is supported by two publications that indicate these two factors are associated with increased risk of death [44,45]. Our study had limitations. These are partly related to its cross sectional study design and the fact participants were selected from a single primary health care facility. Moreover, our study might have been exposed to recall bias because we relied on anamnesis to retrospectively reconstitute the first hand past experience of our participants. However our clinical findings, ultrasound, laboratory, and endoscopic were in keeping with the participant’s account of UGIB [30,46-49].
Our study high lights upper gastrointestinal bleeding is a common health problem in rural SSA. In addition, the study provides an up-to-date profile of UGIB in rural SSA where schistosomiasis is endemic. These are important findings for populations at risk of hepatic schistosomiasis, for better case management, improvement of health management information systems, and further research in SSA.
What is known about this topic
What this study adds
The authors declare no competing interest.
CKO, PO, FK, LR: development of the protocol; CKO, LR, PA, ENB: implementation of protocol and data collection; CKO, ENB: data management and analysis; CKO, PO, FK, LR, PA, ENB: manuscript formulation and review. All authors have read and agreed to the final version of this manuscript and have equally contributed to its content and to the management of the case.
The authors acknowledge the Medical Education for Services to All Ugandans (MESAU) a National institute for health grant (http://www.fic.nih.gov/Grants/Search/Pages/MEPI-R24TW008886.aspx). Project Number: 1R24TW008886-01, the scheme provided a medical education grant to CKO to carry out this research project. However, the funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Table 1: baseline characteristics of all participants
Table 2: a contingency table summarizing different of episode categories of upper gastrointestinal bleeding and total number of episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding by various clinical factor variables
Table 3: a summary of the regression coefficients, their standard errors, constants, p-values and criterion measures for the 3 best-fit models
Figure 1: average marginal effects with 95% confidence intervals of factor variable from model-3
|The Pan African Medical Journal articles are archived on Pubmed Central. Access PAMJ archives on PMC here|
Volume 26 (Jan - Apr 2017)
This article authors
|On Google Scholar|
Navigate this article
Tables and figures
|Table 1: baseline characteristics of all participants|
|Table 2: a contingency table summarizing different of episode categories of upper gastrointestinal bleeding and total number of episodes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding by various clinical factor variables|
|Table 3: a summary of the regression coefficients, their standard errors, constants, p-values and criterion measures for the 3 best-fit models|
|Figure 1: average marginal effects with 95% confidence intervals of factor variable from model-3|
Rate this article
Popular articles in Research
|1||Epilepsy and Education in developing countries: a survey of school teachers’ knowledge about epilepsy and their attitude towards students with epilepsy in Northwestern Nigeria|
|2||Profil épidémiologique et clinique de la tuberculose dans la zone de santé de Lubumbashi (RD Congo)|
|3||Impact de la varicocèle sur le volume testiculaire et les paramètres spermatiques|
|4||Assessment of renal function and electrolytes in patients with thyroid dysfunction in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: a cross sectional study|
|5||Implementation challenges of free maternity services policy in Kenya: the health workers’ perspective|
|6||Health care utilization among rural women of child-bearing age: a nigerian experience|
|7||Pan African Medical Journal (Pamj) and African Field Epidemiology Network (AFENET): A partnership for the future of medical publishing in Africa|